Ukraine Peace Talks Latest: A New Round Before Christmas?
Zelensky Agrees to Talks Before Christmas as Moscow Rejects the Guarantee Kushner Described
Ukraine peace talks latest: Zelensky says the US wants a new round before Christmas and he agreed. Moscow rejects the Article 5 guarantee Kushner described.

In this article
Context
Volodymyr Zelensky said on Saturday 21 November that Washington wants the next round of peace talks between Ukraine, Russia and the United States to happen before Christmas, and that he has said yes. “The American side said it wants to get this done before Christmas. I agreed,” he told journalists in a chat briefing. “The sooner there’s a result, the better.”
Two days earlier in Berlin, US envoy Jared Kushner said Russia had been brought round to a security guarantee for Ukraine “based on Article 5”, NATO’s mutual defence clause. On Friday Russia’s deputy foreign minister Sergei Ryabkov called any formula for Ukraine’s “quasi-membership” of NATO “unacceptable to us”. On Saturday Zelensky said he had seen no such guarantee on paper.
The last round, held in Abu Dhabi on 10 and 11 November, ended with agreement on humanitarian steps and on talking again. Silent Dossier set out the state of play on 17 November in Is the Ukraine War Ending? What Trump and the Kremlin Said.
Key takeaways
- Zelensky said on 21 November that the US wants a three-way round before Christmas and that he agreed; national security advisers will first prepare the agenda, by video or in person.
- Kushner said on 19 November that Russia was “comfortable” with an Article 5-based guarantee for Ukraine. Ryabkov rejected “quasi-membership” of NATO for Ukraine the next day.
- Zelensky called NATO membership the clearest and cheapest guarantee and said any alternative “must be on paper” and last “preferably forever”.
- Vladimir Putin said in Shenzhen on 19 November that Russia would “not make agreements” after the strikes on the Crimean Bridge.
What Zelensky said about the Christmas round
Zelensky spoke on 21 November, a day after Russian missiles damaged three river crossings in Kyiv, Kyiv’s mayor said. The quotations here are Silent Dossier’s translation of his Ukrainian.
On the format, he said: “Our national security advisers will have a series of contacts, maybe by video, maybe in person,” in order “to prepare the agenda, that is, the content for the meeting,” with the date and place to follow, he said.
He floated the Group of 20 summit, which President Donald Trump hosts at his Doral golf resort near Miami on 14 and 15 December, as a possible setting for a meeting of the three leaders. Washington invited Putin to that summit in September. Ukraine, which is not a G20 member, has no invitation. “Many leaders have proposed that the American side officially invite Ukraine to the G20,” Zelensky said. “We haven’t received an invitation yet; if we do, we will definitely attend.”
He also said Kyiv had sent the United States and Ukraine’s human rights ombudsman updated lists of occupied villages in the Kherson and Zaporizhzhia regions where it wants evacuation missions for civilians.
What Kushner, Ryabkov and Zelensky said about Article 5
Kushner spoke at a news conference in Berlin on 19 November, after a meeting of the Coalition of the Willing, the group of governments that has pledged to back Ukraine after any ceasefire. He said he and fellow envoy Steve Witkoff had “gotten the Russians comfortable with the concept that any security guarantee for Ukraine would be based on Article 5.” He said Trump was “open” to such a guarantee, but “obviously, it has to be in America’s interest.” He added: “We do believe that Russia having Europe at the table will be essential for ending the war.”
At the same meeting French President Emmanuel Macron urged allies to “reopen the question” of Ukraine’s membership of NATO.
Ryabkov answered on 20 November in remarks carried by Russian media. He said “the notion of a formula for Ukraine’s quasi-membership of NATO” was “unacceptable to us”, and that Ukraine must first “recognize the irrevocable nature of our demand that this state must not join NATO.”
“Article 5 is collective defense,” Zelensky said on 21 November. What remains unclear, he said, “is who exactly this collective would consist of,” and “how it would defend us, and whether it would be prepared to repel the aggressor.” His answer to that: “This must be on paper. So far, I have not seen such commitments on paper.” On how long: “We need guarantees not for two years, but preferably forever. At least for decades.”
Trump has a little over two years left in office. Zelensky’s “two years” points at that date.
What Putin and Merz said after Shenzhen and Berlin
Putin met Trump and Chinese President Xi Jinping in Shenzhen on 19 November, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit. Speaking to reporters afterwards, he said: “However, we will not make agreements after strikes on the Crimean Bridge. We will respond to these strikes.” He promised a response more painful than the attack. Ukraine had struck the bridge, which links Russia to occupied Crimea, three times that week; Silent Dossier described the damage in Crimean Bridge Attack Today: What Was Hit and How Badly.

The same day in Berlin, German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said “we welcome the United States’ move to initiate new negotiations with Russia.” He said partners were looking for a neutral venue, with the United Arab Emirates one option, and that no date was set. Of the Shenzhen meeting he said a “Yalta format cannot bring peace”, recalling the 1945 conference at which the wartime powers divided Europe.

Zelensky said on 21 November: “First of all, Putin’s ‘Yalta 2’ did not work out,” he said. Shenzhen produced no public agreement on Ukraine or on borders.
Analysis
What is an Article 5-style security guarantee?
Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty says an armed attack on one member “shall be considered an attack against them all”. Each ally then takes “such action as it deems necessary, including the use of armed force”. The response is not automatic, said Ian Lesser, a distinguished fellow at the German Marshall Fund of the United States, on 20 November: “It is a political decision taken by member states.”
An “Article 5-style” guarantee would copy that promise for Ukraine outside NATO, given by the United States and some European states. Nobody has published who would sign it or what it would oblige them to do. Harry Nedelcu, a former member of the NATO secretary general’s policy planning staff now at the consultancy Rasmussen Global, said on 20 November: “But Russia has to agree to this proposal.”
Silent Dossier’s reading: Russia cannot veto a promise between other governments. It can refuse to sign a peace agreement that contains one, and Ryabkov’s condition makes that refusal the starting position. Moscow’s earlier demands on NATO’s eastern flank are set out in Did Russia Demand That Finland Leave NATO? What Was Said.
Analysis
How the statements connect
On Thursday Kushner said Moscow was comfortable with Article 5. On the same Thursday Putin said there would be no agreements after the bridge strikes. On Friday Ryabkov ruled out quasi-membership and set NATO renunciation as the first step. On Saturday Zelensky accepted a pre-Christmas date and asked for the guarantee in writing.
Ryabkov wants Ukraine’s renunciation of NATO on paper first. Zelensky wants allied commitments on paper first, and named NATO membership as the cheaper version.
Kushner called Europe at the table “essential”. The Kremlin said on 16 November that the next round was planned for three sides only. Merz is searching for a venue for a round he describes as including Europe. No one in Moscow has said Europe is now in.
Zelensky gains from saying yes early. A refusal to meet before Christmas would now come from Moscow, and Washington would see it. The risk for Kyiv sits in the setting he floated: a G20 summit hosted by Trump, to which Putin is invited and Ukraine is not.
What to watch
The first marker is the advisers’ contacts Zelensky described. A date and a venue for them would show that the Christmas timetable is real. A Kremlin statement on the timetable, from spokesman Dmitry Peskov or aide Yury Ushakov, would show whether Moscow accepts it.
The second is any written text on guarantees, the test Zelensky set. If a draft reaches Kyiv, its signatories and its duration will answer his questions from 21 November.
The third is the Miami summit on 14 and 15 December, and whether the White House invites Ukraine. Russia’s promised response to the bridge strikes may come first and could set the tone for all of it.
Silent Dossier’s judgment: the Christmas date is plausible for a meeting and implausible for a settlement. The guarantee is the term on which a settlement depends, and the two sides want opposite things written into it.
Follow Silent Dossier
New articles and corrections are posted on our official accounts.
Silent Dossier on Google
Add Silent Dossier as a preferred source on Google (opens in a new tab)Follow us in Google DiscoverRelated



